With the NFL Draft taking place next Saturday, lets take a look at some of the Giants options.Obviously the Giants took a big hit at outside linebacker in free agency this year with Reggie Torbor and Kawika Mitchell. However, I’m tired of hearing the sports media say, “the Giants lost two starters at linebacker.” Lets get a couple of things straight - the Giants lost a back up outside linebacker in Reggie Torbor. Had Mathias Kawianuka not broke his leg against the Detroit Lions Torbor would not have been on the field at outside linebacker. Torbor did a fine job filling in for Mathias, but he is not the starter - the Giants are getting their starter back. As it pertains to Kawika Mitchell - he did a very good job with the Giants this year. He probably didn’t deserve the money the Bills gave him, but thats what happens when you win a Super Bowl. However, let me take you back to this time last season - after Mitchell signed with the Giants - it was not a forgone conclusion that he was the new starter! Gerris Wilkinson pushed him hard in training camp, and Wilkinson could have easily come out the starter. In fact at this time last year Antonio Pierce said Wilkinson would be the starter. Obviously Pierce is not the one who makes those decisions, but it just goes to show that Mitchell was not a lock to be starting at outside linebacker.The big loss for the Giants was at safety with the departure of Gibril Wilson to the Raiders. Wilson has been a very good safety for the Giants since he came out of the University of Tennessee, but he was never an elite safety, and thats the type of money Al Davis of the Raiders gave him. I don’t blame Wilson for leave, but I’m glad the Giants didn’t break the bank to keep him - frankly he’s not worth it. The Giants signed veteran Sammy Knight after Wilson defected, but Knight will merely be a stop gap. It seems like the most likely option for the Giants to make with their 31st pick in the first round will be at safety. If Kenny Phillips is not there the Giants will not go safety. The next obvious options are Linebacker and Cornerback. The less obvious option would be Wide Receiver (though highly doubtful).
S Kenny Phillips, Miami (Fla)
Ht: 6′2, Wt: 212 lbs , 40 time: 4.48
Phillips is far and away the best safety in this years draft. In fact, safety is a very weak position this year, and Phillips is the only safety worthy of a first round pick, but will he be there when the Giants pick? I think there is a chance he will be, but there is a good chance he won’t. With such little value at the safety spot this season, another team may jump ahead of the Giants, and nap Phillips. Safety is a big play / big hitting safety. Phillips needs to learn to blitz better when he makes the jump to the NFL, but if Phillips is sitting there when the Giants are on the board in the first round, I think they have to take him - there are just to many long term question marks at safety not to.
LB Dan Conner, Penn State
Ht: 6-2, Wt: 231 lbs, 40 time: 4.67
Keith Rivers of the University of Southern California is the best linebacker in this class, but he will be gone by the time the Giants are on the board. Dan Conner may be the next option for the Giants. I think the Giants would want a faster LB than Conner to fit their scheme, but there’s no denying Conner’s ability. Conner is also a middle linebacker, and with Antonio Pierce holding that spot down for the Giants he would either have to start on the outside for a little while or play behind Pierce. Conner isn’t a big hitter, but he knows how to tackle - don’t expect him to miss many tackles.
LB Quentin Groves, Auburn
Ht: 6-3, Wt: 259 lbs, 40 time: 4.57
If the Giants were to go linebacker in the first round this could likely be their pick - its the way I would like to see them go if they take a linebacker. Groves is a former defensive end that combines speed, agility and great explosiveness. He knows how to rush the passer and would fit well in Steve Spagnuolo’s pass rushing scheme. Think Demarcus Ware - I’m not saying he’s as good as Ware, but he’s of that mold, and he has the potential to be a stud in the NFL. The only downfall is he would probably fit in better with a 3-4 scheme, and obviously the Giants don’t run a 3-4, but he can play the 4-3 as well.
LB Jerod Mayo, Tennessee
Ht: 6-1, Wt: 242 lbs, 40 time: 4.54
It is unlikely that the Giants take Mayo with their first pick, but he has been rising up a lot of people’s draft boards, and the Giants like him a lot. He was moved to the inside this year for Tennessee, but he has always been an outside linebacker, and thats likely where he’ll play in the NFL thanks to his size and speed. He is an outstanding tackler - particularly in the open field. He has had some knee problems, which could scare some teams off. The Giants will probably take a look at him with their pick, but he’s most likely a second round pick.
CB Antoine Cason, Arizona
Ht: 6-0, Wt: 191, 40 time: 4.45
Leodis McKelvin, Mike Jenkins and Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie will all probably be gone by the Giants are on the board. Cason may be there, and could be their choice. With Corey Webster stepping up in a big way at the end of last season, and the potential that Aaron Ross showed through out the season, this is not as glaring of a need as it once was. However, R.W. McQuarters and Sam Madison are old - so the Giants may consider it. Cason started all 46 games he played in in college. He is a big play threat with the ball after an interception. He has the size you look for in a corner to cover the bigger receivers in the NFL. He ran a good 40 at the combine, but he was never considered a very quick player, which has concerned some scouts.
CB Aqib Talib, Kansas
Ht: 6-1, Wt: 2
02 lbs, 40 time: 4.44
Talib is a big, physical corner. He take gambles every once and a while, which could be bad a times. He does not have the open field speed to stay with receivers deep - making him better in zone coverage. He was suspended for 2 games in 2006 for disciplinary reasons, and we know the Giants usually don’t take players with character issues, however, they did take Ahmad Bradshaw in the 7th round this year, and that worked out for them.
.
WR James Hardy, Indiana
Ht: 6-5, Wt: 217 lbs, 40 time: 4.49
It is unlikely that the Giants take a wide receiver in the first round of this years draft, but if they do it could be Hardy. Sinorice Moss hasn’t done much since he was drafted, and Amani Toomer is getting old. Steve Smith will be a Giant for a while, and Plaxico will be here for a few years. Hardy is a clone of Plaxico Burress. He has phenomenal size, and good speed. He has a great vertical leap, and long arms to beat out corner backs on jump balls like Plaxico does now. Hardy needs to bulk up to be more of a physical receiver in the NFL, and he is a bit raw. He’s also had some of his own off the field issues.